Rubric: show students what each mark looks like

Criteria down the side, levels across, and a total students can work out before they hand in.

Live example

The example: A five-minute persuasive speech for English 9

Five rows, four levels, a total out of 20

A five-minute persuasive speech for English 9

Open the example

The names and numbers are made up.

What to notice

  • Every row has a question under its name. For The other side it's: what would someone who disagrees say?
  • Pick 4, 3, 2, 3 and 4 down the five rows and the bar reads 16/20, with the lowest row named: The other side.
  • Time isn't a row. A note below the grid takes 1 point off for a speech under 4:00 or over 6:00.

The prompt that starts one like it

Make a rubric as a single HTML page for [assignment] in [class]. Use [four or five] criteria, each with a short question under its name, and four levels worth 4, 3, 2 and 1 points. Write every box as what the student did, in words they'd use, with one idea per row. Let students click one box per row to see their total and their lowest row. Nothing should be saved. On a phone, show one row at a time with Back and Next. Then publish it on sharable.link.

A rubric handed out with the assignment is a promise about how the mark will be decided. Handed back with a number circled, it's a receipt. This page has one for a five-minute persuasive speech, written so a fourteen-year-old can hold their own rehearsal up against it, plus what to put in yours. The clicking is for the student. Nothing they pick is saved or reaches the teacher.

Who it's for

Teachers and course leaders setting work that can't be marked right or wrong: a speech, an essay, a lab report, a design project. Send it the day you set the task, so students aim at it from the start.

It doesn't do your marking. You'll still fill in a copy for each student, because this page forgets every click when it's closed.

What a good one contains

  • Four or five rows. The sample has Claim, Evidence, The other side, Structure and Delivery. Past six, students stop reading, and you can't keep the rows apart while someone is speaking.
  • One idea per row. Structure and delivery are separate, and time is a flat one-point rule outside the grid. A row that judges two things can't be scored when a student does one well and the other badly.
  • A question under each name. "Can we follow you?" explains Structure faster than a definition would.
  • Boxes that describe what happened. "You mention that some people disagree, then move on" is something a student can spot in their own speech. "Limited counterargument" is a verdict.
  • Levels that differ in kind. The top box for Evidence wants three reasons, each backed by something checkable. The next allows one that rests on opinion. Swapping "excellent" for "good" isn't a difference.
  • Points on show. Four levels worth 4 down to 1, five rows, 20 in all. Students can see what moving one row up is worth.
  • A total that points somewhere. Once every row is marked, the sample names the lowest one and says to rehearse that part first.

Try it on last year's work

Before it goes out, score three pieces of past work with it: one strong, one middling, one weak. If two speeches you'd grade differently land in the same boxes, the boxes are too vague. If you keep wanting to circle the line between two levels, rewrite that row.

Then give it to one student and ask what the 4 column wants from them. Any box they have to ask about gets rewritten in their words. Twenty boxes in a grid can't be read on a small screen, which is why the sample shows one row at a time there.

How to send it

As an open link. It goes to the whole class with the assignment, and parents ask to see it too. It describes the marking and holds no one's marks.

Every page you publish gets one link that opens in any browser. You choose who can open it: anyone with the link, anyone with the password, or only the people and company domains you name, who sign in with Google or Microsoft. Change the page later and the link stays the same.

Make yours in Claude

Add the connector once, then publish from any Claude conversation and get a link to send.

Add to Claude

Already have the file? Upload it here.

More in learning

  • Slide deck: A talk or a lesson as a web page that moves like slides, for people who weren't in the room.
  • Quiz: A short quiz taken from a link, with a reason after each answer and a result at the end.
  • Interactive explainer: A page that teaches one idea by letting the reader change a number and watch what happens.
  • Lesson plan: One class period written down: aims, materials, a timed sequence and how you'll check what stuck.
  • Study guide: One exam topic on a page: the ideas in order, terms, a diagram, common mistakes and practice.
  • Flashcards: A deck of cards on one subject that flips, shuffles and counts what you know, sent as a link.
  • All use cases

Keep reading